Hilltop Haven in Montauk
Montauk, New York
About this house
5
(41)
Properly
Licensed
Permit name: EH Town Rental Registry
Number: 23-885
Permit name: Suffolk County Comptroller Certificate of Authority
Number: 1682
guests
bedrooms
bathrooms
Escape to our luxurious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath retreat. Relax in the incredible backyard with heated pool & large bluestone patio. Enjoy endless amenities: home gym, AC, BBQ, chef's kitchen, super fast WiFi, smart TVs, tempurpedic mattresses & WFH space. Families will love our kids setup. Explore nearby beaches, bike trails, and local dining. We stock lots of supplies so it's ideal for both relaxation and work. Book now for a memorable stay! Centrally located for your convenience. Pet-friendly.
The space
Enjoy the ultimate Montauk getaway! Superhosts Dana & Jason have packed Hilltop Haven full of amenities vacationers will love. Centrally located & convenient to all, with upgrades like dual primary bedrooms, a home gym with machines, TV & equipment, Tempurpedic mattresses, Samsung Smart TVs, central AC & ceiling fans, WFH desk, USB-A & C outlets, super fast WIFI, fenced in backyard, private heated custom saltwater gunite pool, expansive bluestone patio, large outdoor grill, gorgeous flowerbeds, oversized eat-in chefs kitchen, Nespresso espresso & cappuccino machine, coffee & tea center, indoor & outdoor dining, tons of lounge chairs, high thread count linens, upgraded pillows, exterior lights on a schedule, a shed full of bikes & plenty of beach gear to borrow, you'll be counting the days until you can return. Your local hosts update a vacation guide annually. It's filled with tips and tricks on how to make the most of your Mtk vacation, an activity, shopping, dining & nightlife guide, as well as helpful information about everything in the house and how to use it. Hosts are attentive and in the neighborhood should you need help. We do our best to think of everything so you don't have to. Our house is our only house, it's the opposite of a neglected vacation rental. It's full of all the supplies and items you would find in any lived-in home, making it easier for you to arrive and get straight to enjoyment! From linens to condiments, spices to tupperware, ziplocks, tinfoil, tp, tissues, paper towels, soap, lotion, laundry & dish pods, stain removers and four laundry machines, we stock our house so it's ready for you. You'll find a completely ready kitchen, a full set of indoor & outdoor drink & dinnerware, beach towels, coolers, umbrellas, beach chairs, kids toys, yard toys & pool foutas. Please see our reviews for testimonials from past tenants and get a sense of how well we care for our home and our guests. Please note, we rent every summer to fund upgrades to the house. In 2023 we added on , added the pool & patio out back. The garage and space above are unfinished and remain locked for homeowner storage. EH Town Rental Registry Number 25-789.
Guest access
The garage, an unfinished portion of the basement & the unfinished area above the garage are locked and used for homeowner storage. You will have access to all other areas.
Interaction with guests
We are available if you need us as we stay just around the corner at my mom's house, which is in the same neighborhood. We are available by text for immediate help with anything at the house. Also happy to answer questions about Montauk or give recommendations so you can make the most of your stay. You may see us picking up mail at the mailbox, taking a walk around the neighborhood, or getting something from the garage or storage above it. We have some rental supplies on auto-deliver from Amazon and other brands. We will stop by to pick up any packages that are delivered for us and we will put them in the garage so they are not in your way. If the pool level gets too low, we will come by to refill it. If it gets too high, we will come by to empty it. Occasionally if the gardens need work I may come over to work on them. This is rare. We try to have the landscaping staff do that or have it done when the house is not occupied. If you don't need us, we leave you alone.
Sleeping Arrangements
4 bedrooms • 5 beds
Downstairs King Ensuite Bedroom
1 King
Upstairs King Bedroom
1 King
Upstairs Queen Bedroom
1 Queen
Upstairs Loft/Bunk Style Kid's Room
1 Single, 1 Double
Amenities
Additional amenities
Location
The exact location will be shared when your reservation is confirmed.
Joe
⬤
September 2024
Dana & Jason, Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful home with us. The house was perfect thanks to your warm hospitality, supplied with all the necessities making our stay so comfortable and enjoyable. We've created so many wonderful memories that we'll forever cherish. We couldn't be more grateful, thank you again for everything! Joe & family
Austin
⬤
July 2024
This week has been absolutely perfect & your home made the experience 10x better. We can't thank you enough. We hope you have an incredible (relaxing!) rest of your summer. HEART. Love, Austin, Dayna, Casey, Samantha, Jake & Zach
Zachary
⬤
July 2024
Hi Guys! We're out! Thank you so much for everything! The house was truly awesome.
Kerry
⬤
July 2024
Such a great place to stay with family for a week at the beach... ....close to everything (town,beach ,shopping) but private. Well stocked kitchen! So comfy inside and out. Outdoor shower amazing!
Carolyn
⬤
July 2024
I don’t even know where to begin! Dana’s home is absolutely amazing, and my sister and I had such a wonderful stay. My plan ended up changing a few times and Dana was so accommodating and super communicative. The house is just stunning and the backyard/pool area is paradise. Really can’t wait to come back already!!
Rachel
⬤
June 2024
My friends and I had a great time! Perfect getaway! Place is even better than the photos :)
Rachel
⬤
May 2024
Dana was the best! She gave very clear instructions for all of the amenities around the house and had quite the setup for our entire group! Lots to do around the house between the pool, bikes, or cooking a big dinner! This was also a perfect location, perfectly walkable as well! Would recommend this host to anyone thinking about having a getaway in Montauk!
Laure
⬤
July 2023
There is nothing that you need or want that is not here! The kitchen is stocked with everything you need and is truly a pleasure to cook in! The renovation turned this house from a lovely home into a spectacular one! The interior is spacious and comfortable but the exterior is beyond description. Gorgeous pool, beautiful lounges, a lovely deck and outside dining table. I cannot say enough about how wonderful everything is. And Dana & Jason are a pleasure to work with. Always so welcoming and helpful. We truly loved every minute of our two weeks here. We will be back! Laure & Peter, Erin & Dan & the kids, Lucy & Freddie
Cormac
⬤
June 2023
Dana was very thorough and a great host. We would love to rent from her in the future
Julie
⬤
June 2023
Good Morning! We just left. What an amazing week in your home! Thank you so much!
Jamie
⬤
August 2021
Dana was a perfect host and her home is exquisite! The setting was peaceful, close to the beach and private. Her home was beautifully decorated and the kitchen was gorgeous and had everything one could dream of. The yard was wonderful and the outdoor shower amazing! Thank you for such a great stay! Dana also gave us the best beach tips. Thank you!
Kimberly
⬤
August 2021
The house had everything we needed and was super clean, comfy and really pretty. The backyard is incredible. Love the deck off the kitchen and outdoor shower was the nicest one I’ve seen. The host was really great, helpful and accommodating. Love this house.
Kristin
⬤
July 2021
Dana is an amazing host. She goes the extra mile to make sure the house is perfect in every way and has every amenity one could hope for when traveling. Her communication is excellent and she offers so much detailed information that she has written out and laminated for all guests. We knew just where to eat and the best places to visit, thanks to Dana’s attention to detail! The house is exquisite, immaculately clean, and well stocked. We couldn’t have asked for a better host or a better house. The location is perfect too. We can’t wait to return!
Lisa
⬤
September 2020
Charming 3 bedroom with incredibly well stocked kitchen. I’ve never seen a kitchen with so many amenities. Perfect for us, because we cooked in several nights - especially with Covid. Beautiful walk to the beach. Host was extremely attentive, although we really didn’t need anything - everything was available. All texts with stupid questions were answered immediately. You can tell that the owners care very much about this home- which has clearly been updated. Very comfortable. We really had everything we wanted, and probably more. I would definitely come back and highly recommend this home. And hosts are lovely, friendly, caring people. Could not have chosen a better place for our family. And the beds are very very comfortable.
Jeanne
⬤
August 2020
Stunning property, excellent location and attentive hosts are just a few things that made for a perfect Montauk getaway! No complaints whatsoever! The owners went above and beyond to make sure the house was stocked with everything you could need...and then some. Would absolutely recommend!
Mary
⬤
August 2020
My family, myself and my pets stayed at this lovely modern farmhouse home that was clean, attention to details, stocked with anything you would need, close to everything and owners at your call with any questions! On arrival we were greeted by Dana who took the time to show us around her beautiful home and fill with all the information we needed to know. The online images of her home are great and helped us make our decision, if only they could capture the comfort you feel staying there :-). We loved every moment and were disappointed we couldn't stay another week because of course it was already booked, hopefully though we can return next year! Thank you so much Dana and Jason!
Rebecca
⬤
August 2020
The house was a perfect getaway, located close to the beach and town! It had everything we needed and more for a fun and comfortable stay. Dana is great and we'd definitely come back!
Julia
⬤
June 2020
Staying at Dana’s home was by far our best Airbnb experience! The house was perfect for our family of 5, fully equipped for everything you may need during your stay and the area is absolutely beautiful. Dana is super responsive and we hope to come back to her place next summer.
Melissa
⬤
June 2020
Beautiful home and great location. Dana was super communicative and flexible in ensuring we had a great vacation. Would love to rent again in the future!
Madeline
⬤
May 2020
The house is amazing, beautifully decorated, well appointed with all you could want and more, and full of lovely little touches. The yard is peaceful and private, including a lovely outdoor shower. The location is excellent, and Dana is a wonderful host. Honestly I cannot say enough about what a fabulous place this is. Highest recommendation.
Laurie
⬤
October 2019
We stayed here with our 3 kids for a getaway in the fall. This is a beautiful home in a quiet neighborhood close to town and the beach. The house is sparkling clean, boasts fun modern decor, and is well stocked with everything you could need and more! The back yard was perfect for our kids to play in (fenced in which is a bonus) and we enjoyed dining on the deck. Outdoor shower is glorious! Dana is a gracious host, very organized, and leaves great directions to help you navigate the house, as well as a thoughtful book chock full of local recommendations. We would revisit in a heartbeat!
Laura
⬤
September 2019
Dana’a place was lovely. 6 of us spent the week, the house was perfectly placed right up the block from town. The backyard was a great plus because I brought my dog (350$ pet fee), completely fenced in, outdoor lighting & shower. The kitchen has everything available that you’d need & they have Netflix & stuff on the TV. Beds were extremely comfy! She was a phenomenal host, and very easy to get in touch with if anything.
Carly
⬤
May 2019
A lovely, well maintained home in beautiful Montauk, with everything you need for a great stay.
Caroline
⬤
September 2018
It was a beautiful house. Well maintained and clean. Great, modern kitchen and a large fenced in yard which was nice for kids. It was a great location as well! Host was super attentive and responsive.
Deborah
⬤
August 2018
This house far exceeded any of our expectations. Dana is the perfect host and the house has everything you could need to feel like home. Thank you for everything, Dana! We will definitely be back.
Sam
⬤
August 2018
Amazing property and Dana was helpful and kind. Highly recommend.
Mike
⬤
August 2018
We just returned from our stay in this lovely Montauk home. My only complaint is that we didn’t stay longer. First, the host Dana was incredibly gracious with answering questions prior to booking. We scheduled this trip last minute and the host was responsive to each and every request for information. Upon arrival, which was seemless, host Jason arrived to greet us within two minutes of pulling into the driveway. Again, he was inviting and responsive to all questions. We had two dogs, two kids, my wife and I. The home was the perfect size. The outdoor area which includes a totally fenced-in backyard (perfect for dogs) contains a lovely outdoor shower, deck, grill, hammocks and seating area. There is a table to eat al fresco or inside weather depending. The kitchen was fully stocked with any items that you would need, including pots, pans, cutlery, ziplocks, foil, everything and anything! The washer/dryers were large and conveniently located in the basement of the home. The town of Montauk is a quick car-ride (2 minutes) or bike ride away. If you want to walk to town you can certainly do so if you are physically fit. There was ample free parking all over town including the beach which was beautiful. I highly recommend this property.
Max
⬤
July 2018
The beds and bedding were top shelf. The kitchen is stocked and accessorized better than our own kitchen. Loved it. Washer and dryer are huge and very beneficial. Lovely quiet neighborhood. Close to town and the beach. VERY dog friendly front porch, rear deck, and backyard. That was paramount for us. Owners are very attentive and instantly responsive to any questions. Great entertainment set up in living room and each of the bedrooms. Definite 5 star choice.
brittany
⬤
July 2018
Dana and Jason were GREAT hosts! Their home was the perfect size for our group! Everything was clean and renovated recently. Kitchen was stunning, we cooked almost every night! They left all the linens we would need and were so helpful if we had any questions. BBQ was great and outdoor shower was so handy when we tanned in the yard. So much space we were able to set up some yard games and had a blast! Can’t wait to stay again next summer! THANKS AGAIN!
Guiseppe
⬤
June 2018
My family and I have been coming to Montauk for over 20 years and we have to say this was the best home we ever stayed at. The booking process was very easy. Dana was a pleasure to communicate with. She met us at check in and explained everything to us. And she was only a text away. The house was immaculate!!!! It was fully stocked with everything. We actually felt like we were in our home. The decor was beautiful. We are looking forward to next year's stay already.... Thank you again to Dana......
Suse
⬤
May 2018
Dana and Jason were wonderful hosts. Dana met us upon arrival and showed us around, answering all of our questions. She left us three sets of keys in addition to a fully-stocked home with plenty of extra linens and towels. She even left some baking ingredients and she knew we were planning on making a birthday cake! The home is gorgeous. The beautiful, expansive backyard was perfect for a Memorial Day BBQ and the outdoor shower was a real treat! The kitchen is MASSIVE and fully stocked for plenty of nights/mornings cooking at home. The beds were super comfortable and the TV came with all kinds of fancy features, from Netflix to Bluetooth. The house is on a quiet street just a 15 minute walk from town (about a mile) and is within walking distance of the beach! There was room for our 3 cars in the driveway and for a family of four in the house for a whole week, there was plenty of room for us to spread out and get alone time when we needed it! Highly recommend this lovely home! Wish I could go back all summer!
Wasan
⬤
September 2017
This was the perfect home away from home. Location was fantastic, hosts made sure house was well stocked and super organized. Could not ask for a better stay!
Niamh
⬤
August 2017
Dana and Jason were so helpful throughout our stay and have thought of everything to make your stay comfortable and relaxing. The house was a perfect beach home (well decorated, wifi, tv, helpful hints for the local area). I just wish we could have stayed longer. We would definitely recommend this home for anyone staying in Montauk.
Nicole
⬤
August 2017
Lovely space 5 min drive to town and beaches. Kind and attentive hosts. Home well stocked with essentials and more, great backyard and very clean :)
Stephanie
⬤
August 2017
This home was beautiful and in a great location! We walked to town every day and it was quiet enough to enjoy when we wanted peace. Dana was great to work with and extremely helpful in making sure we had a terrific time. Looking forward to returning!
Laure
⬤
August 2017
This is a great house and is wonderfully equipped. The owners have thought of everything to make your stay comfortable and fun. The shed is equipped with bikes, sand toys, umbrellas and there are tons of beach towels etc. The interior is comfortable and the kitchen could not be better laid out or provisioned. Bedrooms are comfortable, back deck is lovely and fenced in yard was a real plus with a toddler and a dog! One or two hiccups were dealt with in minutes. Can't say enough good things about Dana and Jason. Lovely Couple; lovely home!
Carol
⬤
July 2017
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Dana and Jason's home was beautifully decorated. We truly felt at home. The kitchen had everything we wanted and needed. The fresh herbs outside were such a nice touch. Ending the day with a Mojito made with fresh mint after an outdoor shower as the sun was going down was just perfect. The location of the house was just great. A walk to town gets you fresh Jelly donuts from the bakery or ice cream at John's. Even our little pup Jackson enjoyed playing ball in the large, beautifully maintained backyard. We would absolutely return to this home!! Thank you Dana and Jason.
Kaley
⬤
July 2017
We had an amazing time at Danas house! It was absolutely perfect inside and outside and super walkable to all that Montauk has to offer. Dana was also super easy to work with.
Michelle
⬤
June 2017
My family and I recently stayed stayed at this property for a week, and we loved it. The owners, Dana and Jason, paid much attention to detail when updating the house and getting it ready for renters. Everything from the amenities to the decor expressed their pride in their home...it felt like a brand new house. The house is also in an ideal location, close to town and the beaches, as well as the sound area and the point. Dana was so helpful in making the most of our vacation. She provided many tips and recommendations about where to visit or eat in Montauk. Thank you Dana and Jason for an unforgettable stay in Montauk. We highly recommend this house to anyone who is looking for an exceptional house in a great location!
Jacqueline
⬤
June 2017
Dana was a great host, the house was immaculate and had everything we needed. Very close to town and easy to get in touch with with any questions!
Kimberly
⬤
May 2017
We were very pleased to have been the first rental in this lovely home. Dana and Jason are wonderful owners who renovated their first home with lots of detail and so much TLC. From lovely manicured lawn with fenced back yard which was perfect for our four pawed member and lounged chairs to BBQ area was just wonderful. The house is bright and decorated with warmth and comfort. We have rented quite few homes but this was the first house with plants and beautiful orchid pots in every bedroom and even in the bathroom! It was little touches throughout that made the home extra comforting. They have everything you need and more. The kitchen has a huge island, big sink and new appliances. We enjoyed the Nespresso machine each morning. The house is fully stocked just like your own home. This house is perfectly located, being close to all areas of Montauk. We highly recommend this lovely home for families to enjoy Montauk. We would definitely rent again in the summer. Thank you Dana and Jason for your most warm hospitality and we enjoyed the beers and the wine very much! Also, thank you for providing new bowls for our dog! Your generosity is present throughout your sweet home! Thank you for sharing your beautiful home with us! See you soon.
- 50% refund if cancelled at least 60 days before check-in, then non-refundable.
3:00pm Check-In Window
Guests may arrive and access the property starting at this time.
Check-In with Host greets you
A host or co-host will meet with guests to exchange the keys.
10:00am Checkout
Guests must depart and leave the property by this time.
9 Guests Maximum
The total number of guests allowed to stay at the property, including children.
Child-friendly
Property is suitable or safe for children under 12
No parties or events
No parties or events are allowed on this property
Infant-friendly
Property is suitable or safe for very young children under 2
Commercial photography not allowed
Commercial photography and filming on this property is not allowed
No smoking allowed
Pets allowed
Guest Must Climb Stairs
There are 4 steps up into the house. There is one flight to the laundry in the basement, and one flight to the bedrooms upstairs.
Potential for Noise During Stay
You may hear cars as they drive by or other people in their pools outside. You may hear fireworks as it is summer. The noon whistle blows every day at 12:00pm and will also blow if there is a fire or other ambulance emergency in town.
Pet(s) Live on Property
We occasionally dog sit for my mom, who has an Aussie Doodle named Turtle, or my sister, who has a Double Doodle named Tuna. We are also a pet friendly property. If you have a severe allergy you may want to consider staying elsewhere.
Limited or No Parking
EH Town rental law prohibits more than 4 cars overnight at a rental property. We have room for 4 cars in the right half of the driveway. Please do not block the garage doors.
Limited Essential Amenities
The basement, garage and area above it are unfinished & locked for homeowner storage.
Exterior Security Camera(s)
Ring Video doorbell at the front door records video and audio that is monitored. Ring security camera above the garage records audio and video in the whole front yard and driveway area that is monitored.
Pool or Hot Tub Doesn’t Have a Gate or Lock
The pool is entirely fenced in and all gates are equipped with child proof safety locks. Ask about door and window alarms that we also have, and are a requirement of EH Town rental law.
Nearby Lake, River, or Body of Water
Take your pick: ocean, bay, lake or pond. Montauk has it all and it's all nearby. Refer to our House Manual for details.
from
$2,070.00
/ night
Ages 12 and above
Ages 2-11
Under 2
Furry friends
- This property allows up to 9 total guests.
- Pets are allowed at this property.